Web Content Viewer
bronze bust of president rutherford b hayes sitting on the counter at the rutherford cafe in delaware ohio

Only in Ohio: The Rutherford Cafe

A new presidential eatery is now serving gourmet sandwiches in Central Ohio.

The Rutherford Café in Delaware

Only in Ohio: The Rutherford Cafe

By Heather Rader

Posted On: Apr 18, 2022

The Rutherford Café, located in Delaware, pays homage to the 19th president of the United States, Rutherford B. Hayes. The former United States President was born in Delaware, Ohio in 1822. As his birthplace, the city of Delaware has an array of presidential themed locations and events, including a 7-foot, 700-pound bronze statue in his honor, an interpretive panel of Hayes' life, a bust at his namesake, Rutherford B. Hayes High School, and a historical marker at the site of his birthplace.  

exterior front entrance of the rutherford cafe in delaware ohio

Located next door to his birthplace site, the café is an ideal place to refuel after exploring the historical Hayes sites and Downtown Delaware. The café space is small, with beautiful, exposed brick walls, a repurposed pallet wood ceiling and repurposed industrial tables.

inside view of bar stools and table inside the rutherford cafe in delaware ohio

Although seating is limited, if you can, snag at seat by the front window, it's a great spot to enjoy your delicious sandwich. The gourmet sandwiches are great for takeout as well.  

inside of the rutherford cafe in delaware ohio

The Rutherford Café is operated by the same owners as The Greater Gouda, a family-owned local specialty food and cheese shop. Bringing the best ingredients from The Greater Gouda, the café serves hearty Midwestern fare for breakfast and lunch. With an array of gourmet sandwiches and salads and a selection of vegan and gluten-free choices, there’s plenty of delicious options for every sandwich lover!  

Patrons can expect unique and hearty sandwich creations like the beefy Raging Beast and The Rutherford, a classic Beefy Boy, the Vegan Hero, and an array of morning goodness breakfast sandwiches like Wrappin' Up Sunshine or Greens, Eggs & Ham. All sandwiches can be customized with a selection of bread or wrap choices, ala carte ingredients, and prepared toasted or melted.  

closeup of two sandwiches with potato chips from the rutherford cafe in delaware ohio

For my husband and mine's visit, we selected the Ham A Lot and Beefy Boy, both melted on a pretzel bun. Now, I'm not a food writer, but I love food and can proclaim that both of our sandwiches were incredibly hearty, and they rank as one of the best deli sandwiches I've consumed in years!  

counter with bust on it at the rutherford cafe in delaware ohio

If you're a foodie, you'll want to add this presidential sandwich shop to your list! The Rutherford Café is located at 9 East Williams Street, Delaware.  

For more food fun and Presidential history, check out #OhioFindItHere at Ohio.org

Travel Inspiration

Here are some of the latest articles from our team:

Ohio. Find It Here. Newsletter

Find travel inspiration for your next trip, get the latest Ohio news & find out about great events with our newsletter!